de Gruyter open acces

We appreciate your attitude and express our thanks for cooperation.
Your anonymity to authors will be preserved.

Paper ID:

Type of paper:
original scientific work
review article
short communication

 You can check one or two (adjacent) cells or leave an empty row:  Hi   ?   Lo
 scientific value (contribution to addressed subject):
 technical soundness, topicality (up to date, not obsolete):
 originality (original work, so far unpublished, not a plagiarism):
 copyright (non-violating third party rights):
 paper size (length, extent) check "Lo" if too lenthy:
 title (length, comprehensibility, reflecting the paper content):
 abstract (brevity, informative, containing salient features):
 introduction (not repeating known issues, clearly stated objectives):
 theory (comprehensiveness, extent, coverage, clarity):
 experiment (equipment, methods, data acquisition, credibility, uncertainty):
 discussion (appropriate, relevant and concise):
 conclusions (lucid, concrete and feasible, own contribution stated):
 citations (appropriate number, pertinence, occurrence in the text):
 textual matter (formulations, used notions, style and grammar):
 figures (number, quality, clarity):
 tables (clear, suitable extent - no redundancy or duplicity in graphs):
 quantities (defined, using SI units or conversions are given):
 abbreviations (constrained number, defined before first appearance):

Your recommendations concerning this manuscript:


You can specify your opinion relating particular items in more details here.

A report to pass to author(s):
Inevitable changes: